New York Nine

Baseball the way it was meant to be, down and dirty with brutally honest analysis


Okay, so maybe I was overly optimistic on my ability to bang out another article on the Twins.  One day, nearly two weeks who’s counting right?  Well I guess that’s what happens when you go to law school, one day you’ve got nothing but time, the next there’s not enough because you’ve got papers to write and cases to read.  I digress.   As I was saying last time the Minnesota Twins have shown an exceptional ability to get the most value out of every salary dollar.  While so many other mid-market teams seemed destined to have large portions of their salary in sunk cost of players underperforming (i.e. Jose Guillen of the Royals, Barry Zito of the Giants) the Twins manage seem to manage to know how to invest wisely where market inequalities exist.  Such is the case for Orlando Hudson and his recent contract for one year $5million a few weeks ago.  While many teams have tried to shy away from giving out free agent money to veterans like they used to, the Twins managed to take advantage of the undervalued Hudson and solidify their infield unlike any Twins team in years.
For those who don’t remember, Orlando was in a very similar situation last year as spring training approached.  Coming off a big year with the Diamondbacks, Hudson was a free agent for the first time and was given the dreaded Elias A Free Agent Status.  For those who don’t know, “A” Status is given to free agents deemed the best of the class, who in turn require that the signing team give the old team a first round draft pick, something that teams are reluctant to give up.  Subsequently, despite an impressive season that produced a .305/.367/.450 batting line and a gold glove, Hudson was forced to take a last minute 2.5million dollar deal from Los Angeles.  However, it didn’t take long for Hudson to show the other 29 clubs how sorry they should be for not signing him when he got off an impressive start for the first two months hitting .333/.405/490 with solid defense.   Indeed, it was plain to see early on in his tenure for the Dodgers that Orlando was an all-around solid player, good for 3.2 wins above replacement the year before.
Yet as hot as Hudson began the season, an uncharacteristic cold streak made the beginning of the season seem to vanish from baseballs’ memory.  Indeed, after tearing the cover off the ball in May, Hudson was a disaster in June hitting .222/.269/.343, and while he recovered his Manager Joe Torre seemed to lose confidence in the veteran second basemen.  Although he continued to get at bats throughout the season, Hudson saw his plate appearances diminished in favor of Ronnie Belliard, a veteran who can be serviceable a times, but not nearly the player the O-Dog is.  As a result, by playoff season Hudson was mostly a spectator as the Dodgers fell to the Cardinals, and in truth he didn’t really deserve it.  A closer looker at the numbers, particularly his BABIP shows an extraordinarily unlucky season, hitting as low as .247 after hitting close to .310 for his career.  As these numbers and several other findings show Hudson was a victim to bad luck and circumstance that won’t likely continue in 2010.  An even more in depth look at Hudson’s season by Bill James shows a move out of Dodger Stadium will benefit Hudson greatly this year.  In James’ 2010 Handbook shows that Dodger Stadium decreased both triples and doubles by more than ten percent, a drop that is even more impressive when you consider that his old Park, Chase Field increased triples by 73 percent.   Although we can’t know for sure how Target field will play, it’s sure to be more of a hitters park than Dodger Stadium where he still managed to hit .283/.356/.417. 
Additionally, Hudson provides a great deal of value with his glove, where he has made a name for himself as one of the games’ best.  Already a four time gold glover, Orlando brings a great deal of athleticism to the position, as well as impressive range despite already being 32.  Although Hudson’s UZR wasn’t all that impressive last year standing at -3.7, this is largely a product of his inconsistent playing time, and it still has not hurt his career line of 17.6.  To be sure, second basemen with career UZR averages of 17.6 above average are far and few between in this league, especially those available for a scant 5million. 
This impressive combination of offensive prowess and defensive acumen exhibited by Hudson makes the second basemen worth every penny the Twins paid and more for the season.  Indeed, fangraphs.com valued the dollar amount of his performance last year $11.4million, and it’s hard to hard to argue with those numbers.  Orlando appears poised to significantly improve a Twins team that won the AL Central last year, and in typical Twins fashion they got it for basically nothing.  It’s moves like these that have made Minnesota one of the model franchises in baseball, who now with a new stadium should have even more resources should make things even more uncomfortable for an already nervous group of divisional foes.       



In the vast baseball landscape dominated by the big market teams like New York, Boston, and Los Angeles, it’s very easy to forget about the Minnesota Twins and what they’ve accomplished.  Hampered by a shoestring budget in a market that isn’t exactly what you’d call paradise, the Twins are the team that everyone forgets about, quietly making smart move after smart move and in the process becoming a mainstay of the powerful teams in the American League.  Indeed, despite a payroll that ranks among the lowest year after year, the Twins have made the playoffs five times since 2000, a feat that is only matched by four other teams on the Junior Circuit.  How do they do it?  What’s their secret that no one else seems to know?  In truth, there is no secret to the Twins’ success except for having a keen eye for talent and spending money judicially, as evidenced by the moves for J.J. Hardy and Orlando Hudson.
The trade for J.J. Hardy like many moves by the Twins was both unassuming and brilliant.  Traded in early November while everyone was worried with the World Series, the Twins swapped their talented but inconsistent center fielder Carlos Gomez in exchange for the former All-Star shortstop.  Some of you may remember that Gomez was the centerpiece of the Johan Santana trade with the Mets a few years back, and while it is clear the 24 year old centerfielder has talent, Carlos has considerable work to do before he can be considered a major league hitter.   Indeed, Carlos’s first two years for Minnesota have been nothing short of atrocious, hitting a measly .258/.296/.360 in 2008 and the next year he hit even worse, hitting an embarrassing .229/.287/.337; that’s an OPS+ of 64!  He’s not even close to being an okay hitter!  Now this isn’t to say Gomez has been totally worthless, somewhat making up for his lack of run production with some above average run prevention, posting a UZR/150 of 16.1 and 10.00 the last two seasons, but he still leaves a lot to be desired.  All of these factors considered, it is in fact pretty remarkable that the Brewers would be willing to give up a guy like Hardy when it’s so evident how flawed Gomez is as a player. 
In return for the talented Gomez Milwaukee traded former All-Star J.J. Hardy, a similarly talented, but more established talent.  Still only 26, the young shortstop has put up some gaudy offensive stats  that most teams would kill for, hitting 51 home runs between 2007-8 and posting a pretty impressive .284/.343/.478 batting line in that time.  Numbers like these got Hardy recognized quickly that he was one of the emerging power hitters of the National League.  But Hardy’s bat doesn’t tell the whole story as to how valuable he has been, because he’s been one of the better defensive shortstops as well.  Hardy’s UZR/150 for 2007-8 were above average and at times spectacular, posting numbers as high as 16.7 and averaging around 11.5.   In sum, combining a great bat with gold glove caliber defense, Hardy established himself as one of the more valuable and irreplaceable young players in all of baseball by the summer of 2008.    For a point of reference, Fangraphs.com put Hardy’s 2008 value as an astounding $22.6 million, or five wins above a replacement player; the guy is no joke.
Now of course this is not the whole story with Hardy, and the most recent numbers aren’t nearly as kind to the young shortstop.  Coming off an All-Star year there were a lot of expectations on Hardy, but for some reason or another expectations were not met.  For the year Hardy hit a rather pedestrian .229/.302/.357, with an OPS+ 76 that eventually earned him a demotion to AAA for the remainder of the season.  To be sure, there is no way to sugarcoat Hardy’s disappointing season, but there are a lot of reasons to suggest that he still can be valuable and at best return to form this year.  For one, J.J. at 26 is still relatively young and still has time before he hits his prime.  For another, Hardy’s BABIP was .241, an extraordinarily low number that suggests that a lot of his misfortune could possibly be the product of bad luck.   Finally, Hardy is at the very least still an above average defender, posting a UZR/150 of 8.6 last year, the same number he had the season before.  None of these factors ensure that Hardy will go back to hitting 26 home runs and playing gold glove defense, but they are at the very least encouraging.
To be sure, it seems that the Twins here made a move that can only improve their team for 2010 and beyond.  Even when J.J. Hardy was at his worst last season he still was a better hitter than Gomez has ever been, along with comparable defense at a more demanding defensive position, how can they lose?  It’s a move that makes a lot of sense for the Twins and is consistent with their long history of being a smart organization.  Even when they make mistakes, like they did with Gomez, the Twins appear to be properly equipped to handle it thanks to great scouting and an eye for the numbers like the ones I showed you here in order to make something out of nothing.  Of course it’s entirely possible that a talented athlete like Carlos Gomez will finally “figure it out” and become a major league hitter and prove the Twins to be foolish, but as the numbers suggest there isn’t a lot of hope for that happening when the guy can’t get on freaking base.  In short, the Twins know this better than most teams do, which is why they seem to be able to grab talent out of thin air and continue to be one of the more successful franchises in baseball. 
Part Two of my take on the Twins will hopefully be up tomorrow, assuming I get my reading done at a reasonable time.

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

All The Talent in the World


I can’t say that I’ve ever gotten a request for an article, but when someone gives me an excuse to write about something Yankee related, a Yankee prospect no less, I have to jump at the opportunity.  Jesus Montero, for those who aren’t familiar with the young Venezuelan, is a twenty year old catching prospect and is arguably the most talented prospect the Yankees have had since Derek Jeter.  Conversely, Montero is also  one of the most controversial prospects in that time as well.  Indeed, talent evaluators like Baseball America and Baseball Prospectus are decidedly torn about where the future lies for the 6’4 catcher.  Can he stay at catcher?  Is there a spot for him in the Yankees lineup with all the veteran players signed to long term deals?  These answers and more remain to be seen, but what seems clear is that wherever he’ll play, Montero will hit.
It is fashionable to deride Yankee Prospects as being overrated by the media and Yankee fans, but Jesus Montero’s talent cannot be overstated.  Indeed, Baseball America has recently put out their top 25 prospects in all of baseball list and they put Montero at number five.  John Manuel, noted talent evaluator calls Montero “The Minors Best Hitter,” and when you look at the ridiculous numbers he’s put up while only being twenty this season it’s easy to see why.    Starting in 2007, Montero made his debut in the pitcher friendly Gulf Coast League and hit .280/.366/.421 with three homes and six doubles in 33 games.  Not too shabby for a 17 year old kid who’s learning to catch at a professional level, but it was the 2008 during his first full season where Montero truly distinguished himself as an elite prospect.  The Yankees placed him in the South Atlantic League, a tough league for an 18 year old to handle, and he met the challenge handily, hitting .326 in 171 games and finishing in the top ten in runs scored with 86, 34 doubles, 87 RBI, and 258 total bases.  In addition, Montero hit seventeen home runs, good for twelfth in the league.  These are impressive numbers for any 18 year old prospect, but for an 18 year old who’s playing the demanding position of catcher is doubly impressive.
In 2009, Montero continued his hot hitting ways as he abused minor league hitters at multiple levels.  Beginning the season in High-A Ball, Montero made it very easy for the Yankees to move him up quickly, hitting an insane .356/.406/.583 in 180 bats, smacking eight homes and fifteen doubles in that time.  From there, Montero was moved to Double A where he continued his hot hitting as one of the youngest playing in the league posting a .317/.370/.539 batting line with another nine home runs and 33 RBIs in 44 games.  Unfortunately, Montero’s season was cut short in August with a hand injury, limiting his games played last season, but it seems to have been enough for many to anoint him the best bat in the minors with considerable ease.   From all accounts, the sky is the limit for Montero in the majors, and has already drawn comparisons from such other talented right handed hitters like Manny Ramirez.  This seems like hyperbole, but in truth there is no other prospect or young player in the game today more poised to reach those heights as a hitter.  Montero possesses a great eye at the plate, and a smooth, level swing that enables him to hit for average, but also power, and lots of it.  In the scouting scale of 20 to 80, with 80 being the highest, Keith Law of ESPN and John Manuel of Baseball America put his power at 80, thanks to his quick bat and powerful frame.  To be sure, as a Yankee fan there’s not much to dislike about this kid’s bat and the potential to have a perennial All-Star waiting in the wings.
Now I’m sure some of you are wondering why I said that Montero is a controversial prospect considering all the off-the charts good stats I just rattled off, but there is an area of concern for Montero for is glove.  As mentioned earlier, Montero is only twenty years old and he’s already listed at 6’4 and 225 pounds, with considerable room to grow.  Subsequently, there is a lot of concern within Yankee management and the talent evaluators out there that Montero simply won’t be too big to play there for any extended period.  Indeed, traditionally a position where guys are small, a guy the size of Jesus’ is going to be more susceptible to wear and tear having to be in the catcher position all game for 162 games.
 Further, even if Montero can handle the rigors of the position, he’s not exactly Johnny Bench back there defensively.  With a long and slow throwing motion and not a whole lot of athleticism, Montero so far as proven to be a defensive liability behind the plate, so much so that there is a lot of doubt as to whether he’s even playable behind the plate.  For most teams this wouldn’t be a problem, as most teams could simply slot him over at first base, but with Mark Teixeira signed for the next six years, first base isn’t really an option for Montero.  From there, things get dicey as to where Jesus can fit on this team because of the plethora of old players on the Yankee roster.  If the Yankees were to decide to make Jesus a full time DH, this would create problems as Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez get older and closer to forty.  Neither of those guys will be able to play their current position indefinitely, and it seems likely that at least one of them will need to DH as the years go by, leaving yet another potential lineup spot for Montero filled.  The answer to this quandary remains unclear, but what is clear that Cashman is going to have to get creative to fit him in somewhere soon.
No one can know for sure exactly how good Jesus Montero will be, but he’s certainly more equipped than most to succeed at a very high level in the majors.  Still only twenty, Montero still has a lot of time to grow and develop as a player, and the player that he could grow into could be something very special.  It’s possible that the Yankees will be unable to find a suitable spot for him and eventually trade him for major league talent as they are apt to do, but as a Yankee fan I really hope that doesn’t happen.   As far as I know, the Yankees haven’t had a power hitting prospect with this much potential since maybe Mickey Mantle, and I’d hate to see him develop and flourish somewhere other than the Bronx.  Hopefully Cashman feels the same way.
On a side note, if you want to submit a suggestion for me to write an article, just let me know and I’ll see if I can’t mess it up too bad.  Thanks for reading.

Friday, February 5, 2010

Lincecum wants to get paid


This time of the year is always the hardest to find anything decent to write about in the world of baseball.  Only weeks away from pitchers and catchers reporting in spring training (thank God), teams have pretty much finalized all their important roster spots, and all the important free agents have signed deals by this point (Cough cough Johnny Damon Cough).  All of this adds up to a pretty boring few weeks for a sports fan who doesn’t have a team in the Super Bowl and doesn’t give a shit about basketball and hockey like me.  Thankfully, there are a few interesting under the radar stories going on in baseball that to the untrained eye may appear to be unimportant, but in actuality could be a great indicator of what’s to come in the next few years.  One such case is the upcoming arbitration case of Tim Lincecum and the San Francisco Giants.  Lincecum, only 25 and coming off his second straight Cy Young Award, is easily one of the best pitchers in baseball already and is finally eligible for a raise via arbitration.  However, if the reports about the initial offers are correct, it seems that it’s getting pretty ugly pretty quickly between the two parties.  Lincecum is asking for $13 million for this season, a number that would obliterate Ryan Howard’s prior record of $10 million, but the Giants are trying to lowball him with an $8 million offer.  Now to you and me normal people $8 million sounds like a pretty sweet deal, especially when you consider this would be a significant increase from his $400,000 salary last year, but the Giants’ decision to be cheap now could hurt them in the long run.  Bad feelings from a hard fought arbitration could ultimately push Lincecum away when it comes time for free agency, and the Giants can’t let that happen because he’s simply too good to lose.
A lot has been written by the wiry right hander in major sports periodicals, but it’s truly difficult to understate how absolutely sick Tim Lincecum is at pitching.  At  5’11” and 170 pounds, Lincecum certainly doesn’t strike the average person as really intimidating, but few pitchers in the history of the game have so thoroughly dominated the game from the get-go as he has.  Drafted in the first round out of Washington University, Lincecum was in the majors after only pitching an unheard of 62 innings in the minor leagues because he was simply outclassing hitters.  In those 62 innings, Lincecum struck out 104 hitters, only gave up 26 hits and walked 23; that’s ridiculous.  It’s hard to emphasize how unprecedented this level of dominance is, but consider for a moment that Jon Lester, Zack Greinke, Josh Beckett, and CC Sabbathia all pitched at least 450 innings before they were ready to handle the rigors of major league pitching.  Little Timmy Lincecum was ready in 62 innings and never turned back.
After getting to the majors, most pitchers go through a period of adjustment to major league hitters due to the dramatic jump of talent they’re facing; the same cannot be said about Lincecum.  Only 22 years old at the time, Lincecum came up to the major league roster and dazzled hitters with his blazing fastball and his wicked curve.  In 146 innings, Lincecum struck out 150 while only walking 65, to the tune of a 4.00ERA.  He kept hitters to a crazy .228 batting average and gave up only .7 home runs per nine innings, and here’s he crazy part, he was even better than those numbers say.  FIP or fielding independent pitching, put Lincecum’s ERA at only 3.63, suggesting that if Lincecum didn’t have bunch of bums defensively like Barry Bonds playing for him he would have been even better.  To be sure, it’s very rare that you see a pitcher dominate this well so early, and the scary part is he got a lot better.
Expectations were high for Lincecum in 2008 and it’s pretty easy to say he exceeded those expectations and more with his first Cy Young Season in only his first full season in the majors.  In 227 innings, Lincecum managed to win 18 games for an absolutely atrocious Giants team thanks to his utter dominance on the mound.  Lincecum struck out 265 men that year, while bringing his walk rate down from 4.0 per nine to 3.3 per nine and his WHIP from 1.28 to 1.17.  Fangraphs.com valued his performance at an astounding 7.5 wins above replacement player and a salary $33.7million that year, and it’s easy to see why.  The guy just embarrassed hitters out there, and earned himself national acclaim for it.
One would think that Lincecum would be due for some sort of speed bump or sophomore slump going into 2009, but in fact he just keeps getting better, how is this possible?  Tim lowered his ERA to 2.48, lowered his walks again from 84 to 68, and lowered his WHIP to 1.05 thanks to his improved changeup, a pitch that baseballanaylsts.com lists as the most effective pitch in baseball last year, and it’s his third pitch!  Although he only won 15 games last year for a similarly shitty Giants team, Tim got the Cy Young, and it’s hard to argue with the voters on this one.  The best pitcher in the National League just got better, and just because his team has a bunch of stiffs that couldn’t muster a few runs to get him the wins they couldn’t let his prodigious deeds go unrewarded.
Okay, so I’m sure you’re wondering still “well that’s all well and fine, but why does he deserve the highest arbitration number in baseball history?  $8 million is nothing to scoff at, and it’s the best for a pitcher ever, what gives?”  To be sure, an award of $8 million would be nice, and even if the arbitrator split the difference at say $10.5 million you couldn’t feel all that sorry for the guy, but the point is this guy is historically great on so many levels, why try to piss him off?  Despite years of bungling drafts and trades by signing veteran guys and getting older and older ever year, the Giants stumbled upon a guy who’s dominance is arguably in the same pantheon of some of the all time greats like Koufax in ’66 or Pedro in 99’; you managed to get this right, isn’t it worth the extra $5million to ensure that he stays happy and wants to stay in San Francisco?  This guy’s potential is unlimited, already one of the top five pitchers in the game at 25, this is the guy you spend money on, this is the guy that is worth overpaying for, but the Giants don’t seem to get it.  I for one feel sorry for the Giants fans, because Lincecum has already expressed his displeasure with the Giant’s handing of these negotiations and it’s hard to argue with him.  He’s been the best or among the best wherever he’s been and deserves every penny he wants. 

Friday, January 29, 2010

Some Thoughts on Johnny Damon


Of all the topics that have been discussed in the Yankee Universe these last few weeks, Johnny Damon and his status with the team has been the most hotly discussed by fans everywhere.  Coming off a remarkable postseason run, including one of the oddest and smartest baserunning moves I’ve ever seen in Game 2 of the World Series, fans generally have strong feelings on veteran outfielder.  Damon has been one of those guys fans like to have on their teams, excellent hitter who works the count and can steal some bases, but probably more specifically he’s been a great “clubhouse guy.”  To be cliché Johnny has always been a player that looked like he was having fun out there, always with a smile on his face and a hop in his step, and fans responded to his excitement for the game and bubbly personality.  But it seems that despite his prodigious contributions to the team, Cashman and the Yankee management decided that Johnny was too expensive, instead choosing to go with the speedy Brett Gardner along with Swisher and Granderson, as well as recently signing Randy Winn to be the backup; was this the right move, or are the Yanks just being cheap?  Time will only tell whether opting to move on from Johnny Damon will pay off, and while I’ll miss seeing him play I can see why they did it.
I mentioned above that Johnny is a veteran outfielder, and at 37 it’s easy to see that his best days are behind him.  Indeed, especially on the defensive end, Johnny has clearly lost a step since he first signed with the team and it has affected his range significantly.  Signed originally as a centerfielder, Johnny was quickly moved to left field in his second year and every year his numbers in the field have worsened.  After starting strong in left field with a respectable UZR of 7.5, his numbers have trended downward to last season when he a horrible -9.2, and an even more embarrassing -12.1 UZR/150, a number that ranked Johnny as the worst left fielder in the game.  Similarly, the other defensive stats are equally unkind to Johnny, most notably, RngR or Range Runs Above Average went down from 7.0 to -3.7 (zero is league average for both stats).  Of course, defensive metrics are still not a perfect measure of a player’s ability, but when you watch Damon it’s pretty plain that Johnny is no longer an effective defensive outfielder.  Time and time again Johnny was not able to get to balls that he should have, and all those missed opportunities add up to extra runs for the other team, and this is something the Yankees could not afford to live with anymore.  Compare this to Brett Gardner’s numbers, where he posted an impressive 9.5 UZR and an even more impressive UZR/150 of 69.5, a number that was the best in the game (yes you read that right, Brett Gardner of all people, the dude who’s like five feet tall and kind of looks like a cro-magnon man, was the best defensive centerfielder in all of baseball according to UZR).   Some fans may not feel that defense is that important, but it is clear that the Yankees do.  A run saved is as good as a run earned, and by eliminating Damon from their roster the Yankees should be much better in this regard.
Of course, defense is only half of the story, and offensively Johnny has been a vital cog in the Yankees hitting machine during his tenure.  Putting up impressive OPS+ numbers the last two years of 118 and 126, Johnny has been excellent in all facets of hitting, particularly last year when he hit a respectable .282/.365/.489 line last year while hitting in the leadoff spot.  He hit for power, hit for average, and probably most importantly he got on base and produced runs, with 107 last year.  And yet while these numbers are impressive, there are serious concerns as to whether he can keep that up.  Indeed, looking at Damon’s home and road splits last year, it seems plain that those numbers have been significantly inflated by playing half of his games in cozy Yankee Stadium, posting a 136 OPS+ last year, while only 117 on the road; can Damon expect the Stadium to be so forgiving next year?  Further, entering his age 37 season, there is reason to believe that those numbers will only get worse next year, with several projection systems including those by CHONE and Bill James both anticipating his home runs will go down from 24 to 17, as well as a steep decrease in batting average.  Again, projection systems are not an exact science at this point, but there are many reasons to believe that Damon won’t be able to keep up his production in the years to come.  Johnny has been battling injuries the last few years, and as he gets older those injuries will only get worse as he gets older.  What’s more, while it’s easy to forget this now after the postseason, but Damon was clearly showing signs of breaking down by the end of the season, after starting off hot with a 154 OPS+ in April down to a dismal 82 OPS+ in September.  This could just be a bad month, but this is the kind of breakdown that the Yankees want to avoid.  An old team already, the Yankees just didn’t want to add another old player to their roster who’s susceptible to injury.  Thirty-sesven may not be that old in the real world, but in baseball it’s practically ancient.
Finally, it may be hard to imagine, but it seems the Yankees already have their Damon replacement in a younger and more athletic Curtis Granderson.  I’ve already written about Granderson’s prowess in the bat and the field, but to recap Curtis is a guy who should be able to easily replace Damon’s impact for a lot less money than he was making.  Although he’s coming off an off year where he only hit .249/.327/.453, the project systems by Bill James and CHONE are very favorable to Curtis, both seeing his batting average jump back up to a more respectable .280 and still showing a lot of power, hitting 27 home runs and 11 triples, that’s pretty solid.  He’s not Johnny Damon exactly, but Curtis is a guy who brings a lot to the table, and only 29 years old he should be a productive guy for a long time.
Reading the rumors and speculations about the contract negotiations it’s hard to say whose fault it is that a deal couldn’t be made, but it seems clear that from the beginning the Yankees just weren’t that determined the sign Damon.  While he would clearly help the offense and there may be times that the Yankees will miss his production, it’s pretty apparent that Damon is not worth what he thinks he is, that being 15million a year for two years.  Damon’s glove has diminished greatly over the last three years, and combined that with a bat that may not be as good as it used to be gives us a guy that just isn’t a great player anymore.  I know that I will miss seeing Johnny play for the Yankees, but I am also confident that the plan the Yankees have in place will make them a better team.  It may not be the most popular move among Yankee fans right now, but it’s a move that the Yankees needed to do to continue to improve and keep up with the rest of a very dangerous AL East.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

A's Take Big Risk with Sheets




Ever since the publishing of Michael Lewis’ Moneyball, Billy Beene and the Oakland Athletics have been the focus of a great deal of praise and criticism.  Working on a shoestring budget in a small market, Beene has been forced to squeeze every bit of talent from every dollar by evaluating players in new and inventive ways, and it has paid off handsomely for Oakland.  Year after year Oakland in the last decade have been perennial contenders, winning a handful of division titles and become mainstays in the AL West, at least until as of late.  With the loss of such stars like Jason Giambi, Miguel Tejada, and Dan Haren to name a few, Oakland has had trouble finding replacements from within.  As a consequence, the A’s have been forced to try different things to win.  The trend began last year with the surpirising trade for Matt Holliday and it continues this year today with a surprise signing of Ben Sheets, the oft-injured right hander for a surprisingly rich contract of $10 million.  Ten million may not be much for the likes of the Yankees or Red Sox, but this is a big chunk of change for the A’s, and while Sheets is an unbelievable talent, his injury history suggests he’ll be spending more time on the training table than the pitching mound.
As mentioned above, Sheets at age 31 has shown himself to be an unbelievable talent, when he’s healthy.  Featuring a great fastball with good movement sitting around 93MPH and a wicked curveball, Sheets has shown the ability to make guys swing and miss throughout his career, striking out an impressive 7.6 per nine innings while only walking 2.0 per nine.  This ability to get guys to swing and miss so often has made Sheets a rather successful pitcher, averaging a 115 ERA+ for his career, along with four all-star appearances as the ace of the Milwaukee Brewers since 2001.  All of this bodes well for Sheets and the Oakland Athletics, a team that plays in the spacious Oakland Coliseum that has proven to be a pitcher’s park for those who’ve had to play there.  Further, while many National League pitchers have had difficulty to make the switch to the American League, Sheets’ electric stuff suggests that his transition to the junior circuit won’t be too difficult.  All of these factors add up to a pretty solid pitcher for the A’s, but as we will see below this is only part of the story with Sheets.
To be sure, if you ask anyone familiar with Ben Sheets they will tell you it’s not the on-field stuff that’s the problem with Sheets, its staying healthy enough to be there.  While possessing great talent and at times ace-caliber performance, Sheets has been plagued with injuries throughout his career.  Here’s a list of Sheet’s many stints on the DL;
2001: right shoulder tendinitis (DL, missed 46 days)
2005: Vestibular Neuritis (DL, missed 37 days)
2005: upper back strain (DL, missed 36 days)
2006: right shoulder strain (DL, missed 23 days)
2006: right shoulder tendinitis (DL, missed 82 days)
2007: right middle finger injury (DL, missed 45 days)
 Just looking at that list makes me ache.  Now of course, there is reason to believe that Sheets can overcome these injuries.  After all, none of these injuries are arm related, and allegedly his shoulder issues have been resolved after sitting out for the year, but as true as this may be the trend are troubling.  Now in his 30s, history has shown us that as players age they usually don’t get more durable, and there is a lot to suggest that this will only get worse for Sheets. 
For sure, the A’s have taken a sizable risk in signing Sheets to a contract that awards the righty could earn well more than 10million in incentives.  Sheets has shown to a great talent, but is he going to be worth it?  After all, in the past five seasons Sheets has averaged only 120 innings (counting the zero last year) and hasn’t thrown 200 innings since 2004, what can the A’s reasonable expect? Because I respect Beene and what he does in Oakland so much I want to like this deal, but for the cash-strapped A’s this is a puzzling move.  Ten million is a lot to give a guy who’s coming off major shoulder surgery, and it seems to be a risk that Oakland cannot afford to take.  Then again, I haven’t had a book written about me, so maybe Beene knows something I don’t.




It is very common for baseball writers and fans alike to decry the financial dominance of the have’s of baseball over the have-nots.  With teams like the Red Sox and Yankees seemingly grabbing every big name free agent out there, so many people like to say that these teams use their financial muscle to dominate the game and make it impossible for the small market teams to succeed.  But this line of thinking is short-sighted and in truth overlooking the vast wealth of talent available in the draft and the international market, two areas where the small market teams thrive and prosper.  After months of speculation following Chapman’s defection from Cuba, it was widely accepted that the Yankees or Sox would undoubtedly sign the talented young lefty for an ungodly sum, but instead it was Cincinnati who signed Chapman to a five year $30 million dollar deal today who vastly improved their already promising young staff.  Although Chapman is very raw, the Reds just signed themselves a potentially excellent young starter who has the talent to become one of the league’s best.
Unfortunately for stat heads like myself, there is really little or no statistics on the 21 year old, but it is plain to see Chapman’s immense talent.  Tall and lanky, Chapman throws easy gas from the left side in the mid-90s that reaches as high as 101mph at times.  In addition to his great fastball, Chapman features a wicked slider that falls off the table and is very hard to pick up for a left-handed hitter.  To be sure, Chapman clearly has all the tools to succeed in the majors, but there are questions about his control and his makeup that don’t make the signing a slam dunk.  Indeed, in the few times Chapman has faced top-flight competition the young lefty has shown serious problems for commanding the strike zone, particularly in the World Baseball Classic final where he pitched 6.1 innings and allowed only two hits and struck out eight but also walked four.  This is small sample size for sure, but certainly indicative of the young lefty’s talent and misgivings as a pitcher.   Further, there have been issues whether Chapman can maintain his electric stuff for six or seven innings, with several scouts saying that his velocity has been known to drop considerably in the late innings, suggesting that Aroldis’ future lies in the bullpen as a closer, a development that would make his value considerably less great.
In addition to the stuff on the field, there have been other issues that put into question Chapman’s ability to make it in the Show.  After defecting from Cuba, Chapman signed with the Hendricks Brothers’ Agency who were instrumental in helping the young lefty complete the legal process of getting out of Cuba and getting becoming eligible for free agency this off-season.  However, right before the MLB off-season started Chapman suddenly dropped the agency for another agency despite all the help he had given them.  Further, there have been many reports of Chapman’s immaturity and questionable makeup.  Chapman has already made it clear he doesn’t want to be a reliever and has been called un-coachable by some experts.
Although Chapman is no sure bet as a prospect making it in the majors I like this move a lot for the Reds now and for the future.  It would seem unlikely that Chapman would make the Opening Day rotation, and there are obvious questions as to whether he can live up to the hype, the Reds very astutely spent their money on the most talented pitcher on the market for a price much lower than guys like John Lackey, who doesn’t have nearly as great stuff as the young lefty has.  Personally, I’m happy to see a small market team be smart with their money and get a really talented pitcher.  He’s a prospect and all prospects come with some risk, but a guy like Chapman and his arm are worth the risk, and he could make an already young and talented rotation even better.